Acoustic vs. Electric Guitar: Which Should Beginners Choose?

Starting your musical journey with the guitar is an exciting step—but one big question often comes up first: Should I start with an acoustic or an electric guitar? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. The right choice depends on your musical tastes, learning goals, and personal preferences.

Both acoustic and electric guitars come with their own sets of pros and cons. Whether you’re dreaming of strumming along to folk tunes or shredding rock solos, knowing the differences will help you start off on the right note. One thing is certain: the effort it takes to learn and practice is the same on both. While acoustic guitars are ready to play out of the box, electric guitars unlock a world of sound with amps and effects. Let’s break it down.

Acoustic vs. Electric Guitar: Key Differences

Structurally, acoustic and electric guitars are quite different. Acoustic guitars have a hollow wooden body that produces sound naturally through string vibration and resonance. Electric guitars, on the other hand, use pickups to convert string vibrations into an electrical signal, which is then amplified.

These differences also affect playability. Acoustic guitars tend to have thicker strings and a wider neck, which can be more physically demanding for beginners. But they offer simplicity—you just pick it up and start playing. Electric guitars usually have lighter strings and lower “action” (the distance between the strings and the fretboard), making them easier to press and hold. However, they require additional equipment like an amplifier and cable, which adds to the cost and setup.

Which Guitar is Easier to Learn On?

In terms of learning effort, acoustic and electric guitars are evenly matched. What matters more is how and why you're learning.

Acoustic guitars are incredibly portable and convenient. You don’t need extra gear—just grab it and go. However, the thicker strings can make chord transitions a bit harder at first, which can be frustrating for some beginners.

Electric guitars offer a softer landing for your fingers thanks to their lighter string tension. They also open the door to experimenting with effects and styles, which can keep motivation high. The tradeoff? You’ll need an amp and possibly other accessories, so the cost and complexity are a bit higher.

Both types of guitars can be practiced quietly with headphones or unplugged, so you won’t disturb anyone during your early jam sessions.

Best Guitar for Beginners: Pros & Cons of Each

Acoustic Guitar Pros:

• No need for extra equipment—plug-and-play simplicity.
  
  

• Ideal for building finger strength early on.
  
  

• Great for folk, country, and singer-songwriter styles.
  
  

Acoustic Guitar Cons:

• Higher string tension can be tough on fingers.
  
  

• Less versatility in sound compared to electric.
  
  

Recommended Beginner Acoustic Guitars:

• Yamaha FG800 series: Excellent tone and build quality.
  
  

• Fender FA-115 Starter Pack: Budget-friendly and comes with essential accessories.
  
  

Electric Guitar Pros:

• Easier on the fingers with lower string tension.
  
  

• Offers a wide range of tones and effects.
  
  

• Perfect for rock, blues, jazz, and metal lovers.
  
  

Electric Guitar Cons:

• Requires an amplifier and cable to play.
  
  

• Slightly higher initial investment.
  
  

Recommended Beginner Electric Guitars:

• Fender Squier Strat Pack: Comes with everything you need.
  
  

• Fender Squier Affinity Series: Great standalone option.
  
  

• Fender Mustang LT25 Amp: A reliable beginner-friendly amp.
  
  

Guitar Comparison: Choosing Based on Music Preferences

One of the easiest ways to choose your first guitar is to think about the music you love most.

• Acoustic guitars are best suited for genres like folk, country, and acoustic rock. If you’re inspired by artists like Ed Sheeran, Taylor Swift, or Bob Dylan, this might be the way to go.
  
  

• Electric guitars are perfect for fans of rock, metal, blues, and jazz. Think Jimi Hendrix, John Mayer, or Metallica.
  
  

When in doubt, start with the type that fits the music you’re most excited to play. That motivation will carry you through the challenges of learning.

Beginner Guitar Tips: Making the Right Choice

Here are a few tips to help you decide:

• Choose based on your musical goals and what excites you.
  
  

• Visit a music store and try both types to see what feels more natural.
  
  

• Factor in your budget and remember the extra gear needed for electric guitars.
  
  

Starting out with the right guitar can make a huge difference in your learning experience, so take your time and ask questions. At Remenyi House of Music, we’re always here to help guide your journey.

Conclusion

There’s no universally “better” option between acoustic and electric guitars—only what’s right for you. Both have their strengths and challenges, and both can be perfect starting points depending on your goals.

The key is to pick the one that keeps you coming back to practice. Whether you’re drawn to the simplicity of the acoustic or the versatility of the electric, your passion will lead the way.

Ready to start your guitar journey? Come visit Remenyi House of Music to try out our beginner-friendly acoustic and electric guitars—or explore our handpicked beginner options online.